I guess what it comes down to is this: you killed our relationship. If I had killed it, if you had known about my little indiscretion (and what a gift to you it was to tell you, so that now you can retroactively justify your actions, "See, YOU did something wrong too." Like that makes it ok that when you transgressed you did it upon my full, faithful, loving heart. You stabbed me in a trusting, believing heart. I only threw in my little bit to hurt you. And I am sorry I did. I am sorry because it has made you feel better about your actions, it has given you something to hold over me, distracts from what really happened here, what ENDED us (because it wasn't what I did). But even more so I am sorry because I still feel, even as I did then, like I would never ever ever want to hurt you. It pains me to think of you in pain and shames me to have caused it. So for that, truly, I am sorry. I was weak. I let a hole that you had torn in me the week before (that was closing. Slowly, but closing) let in a temptation that, for one brief moment, made me feel loved in a way I hadn't for so long. And that is weak and pathetic and selfish. I am sorry. I cannot say it enough. I was wrong.
But back to the point. (And I am sorry, I have to make this point, because I want you to have some idea of why I was so mad mad upset...and again, I am sorry for the scene and the slap). If I had killed it, it would have been manslaughter (pardon the awful metaphor, it is both grotesque and stupid, but clear). You murdered it. The difference? Intent. You say oh, all I did was text her. A lot. Hide it. Badly. Act guilty and treat you differently, distantly, treat you LIKE I was cheating on you. But, I wasn't. (Or so you think.) But, what was the point of all that chatter? You don't pick up new friends at a bar, get their phone number and hide their existence and your new "friendship." Did she even know you had a girlfriend? Not that it matters, she doesn't know me. She has no guilt about screwing me over. But you.
What were you thinking? I know you are not so naive to misunderstand what all that banter is. That is where things start. That is where we started. You would be lying to yourself if you believed that is all it would be. What would it have been next? Hanging out when you tell me you are going to hang with friends? Work? Why become these new texting "friends" if you werent going to see one another. And then what? You would be a bigger fool than I believe you to be if you thought that would stay "innocent." You are lucky I found out when I did, so that you could still make some case against being the bad guy. Before all your delusions ran out. Before all the sudden even YOU noticed how not ok "just talking" to "just a girl" really is. It is poison. What I do when I am drunk at a bar? Call you. You never did, I would have always assumed that was just your style, you were never one to ACTIVELY miss me, really. But don't you see, I would never have believed that again. How could I have been ok, when you were shopping for my replacement while I sat at home, dreaming about seeing you the next morning/night? How is that fair?
I don't know if this was just a rookie mistake or if you really were just too cowardly to get out of this relationship in a more noble way or if you were just scared, and freaked out by the idea that there was this path (one where you would have to pay attention to your actions and think about me and make effort all the time) and that it might really work, so you set our relationship on fire out of fear. All I know is that I do believe, against all the odds, that you loved me. If you doubt it now (and I hope you don't, because I don't have much heart left to break), one day you will not. And you should know, that I valued you, and still value you incredibly highly. And you may have moved on to Jill already, but I won't be going anywhere so soon. I have nothing to give anyone else. All my best parts are missing. They are still all wrapped up in you, and in how much I believed in you, and in us. How much I just fucking loved every bit about you.
And please, do not think I am calling you a bad person. You aren't. You are a good person. A slightly you-centric person, one not quite ready to give enough to a relationship and a person who loves you, but that does not make you anything like a bad person. I am very sorry if previous words (spoken or written) have hurt you, I was angry. I AM angry. And, whether you see it or not right now, I have every right to be.
I know it had been rough at times. I am sorry. You weren't great at being with someone and I wasn't great at being with someone who wasn't great at it. I know I said this to you before, but from the very beginning, I had some shadow following me into this. I would say that it felt like I was unimportant, that I was unloved by you. You would cite carefully tracked instances of when you had been thoughtful, loving, put me first.
And you were right. You are right.
I guess I wish I could have figured it out that it was something less tangible. Some basic hesitancy, some core holding-back that eroded my confidence in myself and how you felt about me. I constantly thought it was something I needed to work on, make adjustments for, ease up. And I did. Because the more I felt insecure, the more sensitive and prone to starting a fight I became. I let my feelings morph into one issue (like smoking) that I would NOT bend on, like it was some mission to get you to show me, for real, that you gave a shit about me. And I am sorry for that, it was hard on us both. But there was something faulty in the foundation.
It takes two to make a relationship difficult. I know that. So PLEASE do not think that I do not understand that you might have been trying to fill some void, too. I am not innocent.
But I guess that, when the going got rough, and we made a real plan, came up with a real solution, I reinvested all I had in you. I had a new lease on you. I felt like I loved you even more. I felt like, "hey now, I have admitted MY problem with this, and he has his, and thats the first step, right?"
I guess that is why it hurt even more. That you sold me to a girl on a barstool at Don's for a flirtation. I was high on us. I was high on believing in you. I was down with taking less than I have ever been offered as far as time and attention, because at least I got you. And I wanted you so bad. I still do. I love you so much. It's misery.
I hope that if you read this (and read it all the way through) that you don't just react in anger. I tried to be fair (thought I am sure you would say I haven't been. And fair enough, obviously, I am biased.) I hope that some of what I have said makes sense to you, and I DO hope you feel bad about what you have done. I don't want you to feel like shit, or hate yourself, or say you're an asshole. I just want you to know that you did one big, shitty thing, at least. I have acknowledged what I did wrong too, and feel badly--so badly I almost blamed MY actions for this (And kind of do, I have kicked myself so hard and so long that I can barely stand, I have blamed myself and hated on myself and regretted my actions endlessly) but you pulled that last Jenga block, baby (I tired of the 'straw camel back' saying, ha ha).
I just want you to remember me fondly as, I do you now, in between bouts of rage and crushed sobbing, and as I will--always--eventually. I want you to look back and know that, if even the actual relationship was tough sometimes, that the love was good and true, no matter how it ended.
There will always be a sore spot in my heart for Silver Strike and fire balls and movie theater diet cokes and The Wire and the NBA and podcasts and the best cuddling I ever got. I don't know when or if I will ever really get over you. No time soon, for sure.